What to look out for when choosing your calf milk replacer
Saleable whole milk can have a higher energy density compared with calf milk replacer and is superior in terms of digestibility, particularly in calves under 3 weeks of age.
However, it can be more expensive to feed whole milk when compared to saleable milk prices plus a greater risk of disease transmission such as Johne’s disease. Currently, when comparing cost of milk replacer per litre mixed to the current milk price it makes economic sense to feed calf milk replacer.
Teagasc research shows when the calf milk replacer is formulated correctly from good-quality ingredients and fed according to the manufactures instructions, that calves can grow equally well when reared on calf milk replacer as they would on whole milk diets. Benefits of feeding calf milk replacer are the consistency of the energy and vitamin and mineral content of the feed and the lower disease risk. Calves thrive on consistency. Additional benefits to feeding milk replacers including feeding at a more convenient time and can be labour saving.
When it comes to choosing calf milk replacers it is important to assess the quality of the constituents you are feeding. The only legal requirement for declaration in a calf milk replacer is that ingredients have to be listed in descending order of inclusion. Therefore it is almost impossible to accurately assess the quality of a milk replacer from the label. Here are some key questions to ask before making a purchase.
- What is the dairy protein source?
- Is the protein source of good quality (plant or dairy)?
- What is the energy content?
- Is the milk powder easily digestible?
- Is the milk replacer easily mixed?
- Does the product suit your system eg. Twice-a-day vs once-a-day? Age of calves? Hot water availability.
Protein
Commercial milk replacers usually contain 20–26 % protein. Protein sources in milk powder can be of milk origin (skimmed milk or whey), egg based or plant based (e.g soya, Wheat gluten, peas). Young calves can only digest proteins of milk origin therefore, it is important that the calf milk replacer contains predominantly milk derived proteins from whey and/or skimmed milk. Skim milk powder is a by-product of butter production and whey powder is a by-product of cheese production. A common milk source of protein for milk replacer is whey. On the ingredient list, look for dried whey, whey product or whey protein concentrate (WPC). The difference in these products is the amount of lactose and mineral removed from the dried whey. For example, delactose whey has a high mineral which can increase the risk of diarrhoea and a lower protein concentration compared to WPC (27% vs 35% protein, respectively). The ash content should not be higher than 8%.
Energy
Milk replacers should contain 15–20% fat. Energy source in milk replacers are fat and lactose. Vegetable fats such as palm oil, coconut oil, linseed oil, sunflower oil. Fats are emulsified to a greater or lesser extent in the manufacturing process. The more emulsified a fat is, the more digestible it will be. One of the main advantages of feeding milk replacer over whole milk is the fact that calves fed milk replacer can consume 33% more concentrates over the rearing phase. This is due to the fat content of whole milk is always higher and gives the calf a fuller feeling throughout the day.
Digestibility
The processing method of the dairy protein (both skim & whey) is fundamental for digestibility & calf performance. Factors affecting the digestibility are the cheese type, drying temperatures and handling procedures for the whey protein. Where protein and fat sources are not balanced, some vegetable proteins such as soya and wheat gluten can result in nutritional scours and limit growth, feed efficiency and digestibility. High levels of vegetable fats such as coconut, palm oil or soybean can also pose a risk of scour to calves under 2 weeks of age. Fibre content of a calf milk replacer is considered an indicator of protein quality. High-quality calf milk replacers have a fibre content of less than 0.15%. Fibre originates from plant material used to increase protein levels in milk replacers. For every 0.1% increase in fibre content in replacers, about 10% of the total protein has been derived from plant, rather than milk sources. Additionally cheaper plant-based sources do not provide proper amino acids profiles needed for calf growth.
Mixing
A high quality calf milk replacer should go into solution easily when mixed at the manufacturer’s recommended rate of powder to water and water temperature. Mix until all powder is in solution or suspension without clumps on the surface or at the bottom of the container. It should not leave any sediment at the bottom of the feeder.
Calf rearing systems
Calves can digest milk replacers with whey as the main dairy protein as efficiently as skim-based milk replacers, despite the whey proteins not forming a clot in the abomasum. Research has shown that milk replacers with good quality skim or whey as the main dairy protein can both deliver good calf performance.
The level of skim in a finished milk formula will determine the clotting strength in the abomasum. Skimmed milk (casein) can only be digested after a good clot formation in the abomasum because the enzymes in the small intestine appear incapable of hydrolysing the specific peptide bonds acted on by rennin and pepsin enzymes found in the abomasum. If processed correctly, skim milk proteins can be highly digestible and deliver good calf performance. Whey proteins contain a higher level of essential amino acids than skim proteins. In addition, at low processing temperatures whey proteins can also contain high levels of the immunoglobulins found naturally in milk and colostrum.
Thus, balancing skim and whey content and ratios is important. For a twice-a-day system, a milk replacer with large amounts of skim will result in calves remaining fuller for longer and as a result their appetites for concentrates and fibres will be suppressed, taking the calf’s rumen longer to develop. At low levels of inclusion in milk replacer, the casein in skim will not form a firm clot which can have an adverse effect on animal health and performance.
However, when operating a once-a-day feeding system this can be beneficial. The clot in the abomasum of the calf is broken down throughout the day leaving calves more content while building an appetite for concentrates and fibre. Whey protein is rapidly digested, entering the small intestine from the abomasum an hour after consumption and thus is not suitable for once a day feeding.
First Published 5 January 2023.
Tagged with: Dairy