EBI & Sustainable Breeding

The Economic Breeding Index (EBI) was developed to breed fertile high merit cows that will increase farm profitability in a grass based system. It is a measure of the genetic potential of an animal.


The Economic Breeding Index (EBI) was developed to breed fertile high merit cows that will increase farm profitability in a grass based system. It is a measure of the genetic potential of an animal.

EBI is a single figure profit index that contains data on seven sub-indexes:

  1. Milk Production
  2. Fertility
  3. Calving Performance
  4. Beef Carcass
  5. Cow maintenance
  6. Cow Management
  7. Health


Figure 1: Teagasc MACC curve


Since the foundation of the EBI there has been huge economic and breeding progress made within the industry. EBI has delivered €284 more profit per lactation since its foundation, which equates to approximately 5cent/litre. Recent environmental pressures facing the dairy industry necessitates milk to be produced in an environmentally sustainable manner. Dairy EBI was found to be an effective tool in the mitigation against this. By increasing EBI year on year Glanbia Ireland farmers will qualify for one of the measures set out in the Sustainability Action Payment. In figure 1 Teagasc MACC curve the greenhouse gas (GHG) abatement measure “Dairy EBI” has shown that increasing the EBI of an Irish dairy herd can reduce GHG emissions. As is highlighted, this will result in a significant GHG reduction of 430 kt CO2 equivalent per annum, while also improving farm profitability.


Sustainable Breeding

The overall goal is to produce more or the same output from lower levels of inputs and as a result make the national herd more efficient from both a GHG emissions and financial point of view through genetics and EBI. International studies have shown that up to 30% of the variability in methane produced on a daily bases can be directly linked to genetics, indicating that breeding to reduce methane is achievable. The modern dairy cow is 14% more carbon efficient per kg milk solids than that of cows before the introduction of EBI in 2001. Recent research from Teagasc showed that for every €10 increase in EBI there was a reduction of 1% in GHG emissions per kg of milk solids while also improving profit/cow by €20. This further highlights the direct link with EBI and farm profitability. Figure 2 displays the trend in EBI and the correlation that the right breeding techniques using EBI has on milk production and herd fertility. There is huge scope for farmers to improve the EBI of their herds with recent data identifying the top 1% of herds are €64 ahead of the average herd which can be seen below in table 1.


Figure 2: EBI Trend


Table 1: National EBI Figures


Improving genetics through increasing EBI can reduce emissions by:

  • Improving Milk Production through increased yield and composition from grass thus directly decreasing emissions per kg of milk solids.
  • Improving Fertility in turn will reduce calving interval and replacement rate, compacting calving allowing an extended grazing season where cows will graze and utilise more grass reducing methane.
  • Improved Health resulting in animals having less disease and lasting longer in the herd leading to higher production and lower replacement rates.
  • Improve age at first calving will have heifers calving down at the optimum age of between 22-26 months increasing lifetime production efficiencies and idle time.

How to Improve herd EBI

  1. The herd’s strengths and weaknesses must be established so traits that currently have a low score can be targeted for improvement for the upcoming breeding season. There should always be a focus on milk production and fertility.
  2. A team of High EBI bulls should be selected from the ICBF active bull list when breeding for replacements. A minimum of 7 bulls should be selected to spread the risk of these bulls dropping on EBI score especially when young genomic selected bulls are used. The use of any one bull should not be more than 15%.
  3. Sire Advice on ICBF Herdplus is a useful tool to manage the breeding programme that simplifies the process. It can allocate the bulls to the cows based on their strengths and weaknesses and also manage inbreeding.
  4. The highest EBI breeding animals in the herd should be selected, usually consisting of maiden heifers and first and second calvers. Cows with low EBI should be selected to be bred with beef AI with these animals being bred with beef AI from the start of breeding.
  5. A sufficient amount of AI straws should be used e.g. 55 straws per 10 heifer replacements required.
  6. The Dairy Beef Index (DBI) should be used to select suitable beef sires for your herd.
  7. Purchasing high EBI replacements can accelerate the rate of EBI improvement of the herd.
  8. Genotyping your herd can improve the reliability of the EBI ≈ 25% making the sub-indices more accurate for breeding and selecting purposes while returning up to 4:1 on investment.
  9. Sexed Semen should be used early in conjunction with high EBI bulls. It could be used to compact and increase numbers of dairy females born at the start of calving.


First Published 5 April 2022

Tagged with: Dairy

Processing